7 Winner St. John Fisher SJF 17-5 5 St. Joseph's (L.I.) SJLI 10-11 Winner St. John Fisher SJF 17-5 7 Final Apr. 04, 2026 5 St. Joseph's (L.I.) SJLI 10-11 Score By Periods Team 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E St. John Fisher SJF 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 5 1 7 10 3 St. Joseph's (L.I.) SJLI 2 0 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 5 8 2 W: Justin Christensen (3-0) L: McNally, Paul (2-2) Summary Box Score Game Recap: Baseball | 4/4/2026 3:39:00 PM Baseball Topped by St. John Fisher, 7-5 When and Where: April 4th, 2026 - Patchogue, NY (Gregg Alfano Field) Records: St. Joseph's (L.I.), 10-11 (7-1 Skyline); St. John Fisher, 17-5 Results: The St. Joseph's University, New York (L.I.) baseball team dropped a non-conference contest to St. John Fisher University 7-5 at Gregg Alfano Field on Saturday afternoon. Game: SJLI 5; St. John Fisher 7 Key Players: Paul McNally went 2-for-3 with two runs scored and a walk Alex Johnston finished 2-for-3 with an RBI and a walk John Margolies contributed two RBIs and one run scored Frankie Asaro added an RBI and a hit Joe Thatcher and Andrew Amarando each scored a run Charles Aurant pitched seven innings, allowing just one run and five hits, while striking out 10 batters How it happened: St. Joseph's (L.I.) jumped out to a 2-0 lead in the bottom of the first when Thatcher and Amarando scored on an error by the St. John Fisher shortstop. The Golden Eagles added a run in the fourth when McNally scored on a groundout by Margolies, making it 3-0. SJLI extended the lead to 5-0 in the sixth as McNally scored on another fielder's choice by Margolies and Margolies came home on Asaro's RBI single. St. John Fisher got on the board with one run in the seventh. The Cardinals then erupted for five runs in the eighth — highlighted by Jackson Frey's RBI double, Mario Cubello's RBI single, and two unearned runs on a St. Joseph's error — to take a 6-5 lead. St. John Fisher added one final run in the ninth on a passed ball. Notes: St. Joseph's (L.I.) recorded eight hits but committed two errors. Next Up: The Golden Eagles return to action on Tuesday, April 7, when they host NJCU for a non-conference double-header contest starting at 3:00 pm.  Print Friendly Version Read Full Article Scoring Summary Score By Innings Play SJF SJLI BOT 1st Alex Johnston reached first on an error by ss, out at second ss to 3b to 2b, RBI (0-1 K); Paul McNally advanced to third; Joe Thatcher scored, unearned; Andrew Amarando scored. 0 2 BOT 4th John Margolies grounded out to ss, RBI (1-1 KB); Alex Johnston advanced to third; Paul McNally scored. 0 3 BOT 6th John Margolies reached on a fielder's choice, RBI (2-2 BFBF); Marco Gullo out at second 2b to ss; Paul McNally scored. 0 4 BOT 6th Frankie Asaro singled to center field, RBI, advanced to second on the throw (1-2 BFK); Jake Hall advanced to third; John Margolies scored. 0 5 TOP 7th Ryan Vanderlip grounded out to ss, RBI (1-1 KB); Noah Pohrte advanced to third; Brendan Bucello scored. 1 5 TOP 8th Jackson Frey doubled to left center, RBI (0-0); Austin Droge scored. 2 5 TOP 8th Mario Cubello singled to center field, RBI (3-2 KBBBK); Jackson Frey scored. 3 5 TOP 8th Noah Pohrte walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Brendan Bucello advanced to second; Hunter Fales advanced to third; Mario Cubello scored. 4 5 TOP 8th Ryan Vanderlip reached first on an error by 1b (0-2 KF); Noah Pohrte advanced to second, advanced to third; Brendan Bucello advanced to third, scored, unearned; Hunter Fales scored, unearned. 6 5 TOP 9th Mario Cubello scored on a passed ball, unearned. 7 5 Related Headlines 04.03.26 Baseball Falls to St. John Fisher 03.30.26 Baseball Sweeps Mt. St. Mary's 03.29.26 Baseball Splits with Manhattanville